Christmas Cookie Exchange Ideas 

These Christmas Cookie Exchange Ideas are the perfect way to make your holiday get-together extra fun and memorable.

Picture this — the smell of cookies baking, a table full of festive treats, and everyone swapping their favorite homemade goodies.

You’ll find easy, creative ideas for cookie themes, cute packaging, and crowd-favorite Christmas recipes that everyone will love.

Whether it’s your first time hosting or it’s a yearly tradition, these simple tips will help you plan a cozy, stress-free cookie swap that’s just as sweet as the treats you’ll share.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on one of my Amazon links and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my site—it helps me keep sharing free recipes and ideas with you!

How do Cookie Exchanges Work?

This is a fun and easy way to share holiday treats without having to bake dozens of different recipes yourself. Here’s how it works:

• Each guest bakes a big batch of one type of cookie—enough for everyone to take home a few.
• Then, everyone gathers to swap cookies so each person leaves with a festive assortment to enjoy or gift!
• You can make it as simple or as themed as you’d like—set up cute labels, packaging stations, and maybe even vote on “best cookie” for a little friendly competition.

Christmas Cookie Exchange Rules 

1. Set the date and send invites early. Give guests at least two weeks’ notice so they have time to plan and bake.
2. Decide how many cookies to bring. A good rule of thumb is 1–2 dozen cookies per guest, plus a few extras for tasting.
3. Homemade only! The charm of a cookie exchange is sharing your favorite homemade cookie recipes — no store-bought shortcuts here.
4. Share your recipe. Ask everyone to print or write out their recipe so others can try it later.
5. Package cookies nicely. Use boxes, tins, or festive bags—presentation counts and makes it more fun!
6. Avoid duplicates. Have guests RSVP with their cookie type to make sure you don’t end up with six batches of sugar cookies.
7. Bring something to sample. It’s fun to taste cookies together before packing them up to take home.
8. Have fun! Add a few games, hot cocoa recipes, or a little holiday music to make it feel like a true celebration.

Cookie Exchange Packaging Ideas

From decorative tins to cute cellophane bags and gift tags, the right packaging adds that special holiday touch—and makes your cookies look gift-ready.

Here are some of my favorite products to help you wrap your cookies in style.

Yaomiao 12 Pack Christmas Cookie Tins with Lids for Gift Giving Small Xmas Tin Containers Round Metal Christmas Tins Empty Cookie Jar for Gift Giving Holiday Party Favors (Lovely Style)Landhoow 6-Piece Christmas Cookie Tins with Lids – Metal Xmas Tin Containers for Gifts & Treats (Rectangle)FoldTier 4 Sets Christmas Plastic Candy Jar Clear Cookie Containers with Lids Storage Jar Cookie Tins Snacks Treats Containers for Xmas Home Countertop Kitchen Decorative Winter Party SupplyDIYDEC 36PCS Christmas Foil storage Containers 9 Styles Merry Christmas Disposable Leftover Food Containers with Lids Aluminum Cookie Tin Pans for Winter Holiday Gift Giving Party Supplies(Style B)Zzrywuty 12PCS Christmas Cookie Boxes for Gift Giving, Christmas Cookie Tins with Lids, Holiday Cookie Boxes with Window, Christmas Treat Boxes for Pastry Dessert Cupcakes Mini Cake Candy DonutGOMANCHE 100 Pieces Christmas Snowflake Cellophane Bags, Xmas Snowflake Clear Candy Bags with Metallic Twist Ties for Winter Christmas Party Snowflakes Birthday SuppliesPPRAFDD 180 PCS 5Apotheosis Watch & Learn 100 Pack Christmas Green Cellophane Treat Bags – 10.8 x 5 Inch Plastic Candy Gift Bags with Twist Ties for Christmas, Birthday, Party Favors, Snacks, Cookies & Holiday TreatsMetahom Christmas Salad Plates, 8 Inch Ceramic Dessert Plate Set, Appetizer Plates for Pasta, Side Dishes, Holiday Treats, Dishwasher & Microwave Safe, Set of 6Vloso 20 Rolls 100 Yards Christmas Ribbon for Gift Wrapping,3/8 Inch Christmas Grosgrain Ribbon,Christmas Ribbon for Crafts DIY Holiday Christmas DecorationsSooez 3 Rolls Raffia Ribbon Twine String, 540 Feet Christmas Wrapping Paper for Crafts, Red Green Natural Christmas Ribbon for Gift Wrapping, Raffia Yarn for Holiday DIY Supply, 180 Feet Each RollMEEDEE Crushed Red Velvet & Green Back Double Sided Christmas Wired Ribbon, 1 Inch x 25 Yards, Velvet Wired Ribbon for Christmas Tree, Wreaths, Crafts, GiftsOutus 21 Rolls Christmas Gold Foil Washi Tape – Holiday Decor with Snowflake, Deer, Tree Designs – Self-Adhesive Tape for DIY Crafts, Wrapping, Party Favors

 

Make the holidays extra sweet with these fun, kid-friendly Christmas treats!

Send me the guide

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at anytime.

Built with Kit

How to Display Christmas Cookies for a Cookie Exchange?

Make your table look festive and inviting! Here are some fun and easy ideas:

1. Use tiered trays and cake stands – They add height and make your display look full and elegant.
2. Add festive touches – Sprinkle fake snow, tuck in small ornaments, or add greenery like pine sprigs and holly.
3. Group by color or flavor – Create sections for chocolate, peppermint, or frosted cookies for a visually pleasing setup.
4. Label each cookie – Small tent cards with the cookie name (and who made it) make it easy for guests to find their favorites.
5. Include serving utensils – Use tongs or small scoops so guests can serve themselves easily and neatly.
6. Use holiday platters or trays – Mix and match styles for a cozy, homey look, or keep it uniform for a polished display.

Spode Christmas Tree 2-Tiered Server, Tree-Shaped – Holiday Cupcake Stand, Dessert Display Set, Porcelain Serving Platter, 1010 Pcs Cake Stand White Plastic Dessert Table Display Set 4 Pcs 3 Tired Cupcake Stand Cookie Tray Rack Serving Tray Cake Display Tower and 6 Pcs Dessert Trays for Wedding Baby Shower Tea Party (White)MALACASA 3 Tier Serving Tray, Porcelain Tiered Cupcake Stand, Ceramic Elevated Serving Platter with Collapsible Sturdier Rack,Series PLAT (White, 14 Inch)Manspdier Wood 3 Tier Serving Tray Three Tiered Serving Stand, Rectangle Serving Platter Wooden Farmhouse Tiered Tray, Party Serving Brown decorative tray tray decorSpode Christmas Tree Footed Square Cake Plate – 10-Inch Holiday Cake Stand for Desserts, Cupcakes, and Treat Display – Made of Fine Porcelain with Iconic Christmas Tree Design, Dishwasher SafeKLASKWARE Round Cake Stand 11The Bridge Collection Cake Plates with Sweet Desserts Ornaments – Set of 2 – Cake Stand and Dessert Plate Christmas OrnamentsCBBZJY 3 Pcs Metal Cake Stand Set 8/10/12 inch Dessert Table Display Perfect for Baby Shower Wedding Birthday (Red)Place Cards for Table Setting – 50 Pcs White Blank Tent Place Cards for Weddings, Name Tents Placecards 3.736 Pcs Christmas Place Cards Xmas Name Cards Snowflake Santa Seating Name Tags Snowman Placecard Holders Seating Place Cards Name Tents for Winter Dinner Party Table Wedding SuppliesTesedupoole Christmas Food Tent Labels(25 pack) – Place Cards for Christmas, Table Place Cards – Perfect for Christmas Place Cards, Banquet tables, Buffet food label, Christmas Party-(FZ-a100)Gift Boutique 100 Pack Christmas Place Cards Holiday Seating Name Card Die Cut Xmas Nutcracker Table Setting Folded Paper Tent Cards for Dinner Wedding Tables Placement Party Decorations 2Ninsula 8 PCS Plastic Serving Tongs, 6.3 Inches Disposable Clear Tongs, Kitchen Small Serving Utensil Tongs for Party Catering Buffet Bakery Salad Cookies Ice9X13 Trays (4, Red)Remenna Christmas Sleigh Serving Board, 15 inch Metal and Wood Decorative Platter, Holiday Tabletop Decor

 

If you’re planning a cookie exchange or just love all things festive and sweet, be sure to check out these other fun holiday ideas too!

• Learn How to Keep Christmas Cookies Fresh so they stay soft, chewy, and delicious all season long.
• From Christmas appetizers to festive desserts, find easy Christmas party recipes that will make your holiday gatherings extra special.
• Get inspired with cozy breakfast and Christmas brunch dishes perfect for Christmas morning.
• Stay organized and stress-free this holiday season with my printable baking planner designed to make baking (and gifting!) a breeze.

Make your holiday gathering stress-free and festive with these Christmas Cookie Exchange Printables, featuring invites, labels, and recipe cards to help you host a picture-perfect cookie swap with ease!